Some Sigs ..

[MM357]

What do you think about these signatures..

[img:596971c806]http://www.imw.m-ka.net/images/bigsig.jpg[/img:596971c806]

[img:596971c806]http://www.imw.m-ka.net/images/sigwave20.jpg[/img:596971c806]

[img:596971c806]http://www.imw.m-ka.net/images/sigwavered.jpg[/img:596971c806]


I really appreciate any opinion written in any way .. However I hope you say your opinions in an organized way (as a review or something like that) and followed with a rating. I would be really grateful if you did this.
_________________
[img:75a0ca54d2]http://www.imw.m-ka.net/images/sig_gs.jpg[/img:75a0ca54d2]

[HD]

There's always space for improvement but I'll take it one by one.

Your first signature looks pretty cool. The face from the right corner should be black and white. I think it looks better that way. The text ("MM357") looks pretty weird. I'd suggest you a glass style bevel instead of that metallic one. Or at least a white glowing text. That can also fit in well. Give a try to other fonts. I like the background though.

Since about the second one, it looks kinda strange because you didn't have any thematic colors and different styles are mixed one with another. the face needs a few fixes (look at those glasses) the reflection makes it look strange. Your first one is the best until now.

And finally the third one. Oh well it looks much better than the other one since you're having a color theme and the styles you mixed out there look pretty cool. The text bevel style is also pretty good. The only reason that makes it look kinda odd is the head. You shouldn't have used any gradient for it. I'd advice you to let only a part of the face visible and the other part hide it somewhere in the left border, you know. Sizing it up will also give a nice effect.

Now it's time for rates:
For the first one you get a 9.25.
For the second one you get 7.40.
And for the third one you get 8.50.

Pretty cool signatures out there. With some exercise, I'm sure you'll be able to make really nice stuff. Hope this helped. Good luck!
_________________
[img:1125b12b7f]http://img95.imageshack.us/img95/2860/evsimplesm9.jpg[/img:1125b12b7f]

[spock]

I actually only like the first one..

In the other two the colors don't seem to blend well.
_________________
My new site
My OpenTTD data package

[MM357]

Delivered to HD : Great Feedback.. Of course it helped, I will try these changes. Thanks a lot.

Delivered to spock : Thanks for the feedback.
_________________
[img:75a0ca54d2]http://www.imw.m-ka.net/images/sig_gs.jpg[/img:75a0ca54d2]

[gonz]

Your second signature somehow reminded me of Half Life 2. It looks like Freeman. I like first one the most.

[MM357]

Delivered to gonz ..

You are right ! I really look like him in that one.

That made me laugh continuously for about 5 minutes. Thanks for the feedback and also for the funny comment.
_________________
[img:75a0ca54d2]http://www.imw.m-ka.net/images/sig_gs.jpg[/img:75a0ca54d2]

[drath]

This may or may not be harsh depending on how you take it. It's just my personal opinion that metal-esque or metal looking text is pretty cheesy and not very aesthetically pleasing. That being said, I won't metion it any further.

1) I think this is my favorite. I like the elongated composition. The "a wave of creation" text might be a little too blurry or hard to read depending on your computer resolution. Not really sure about the weird gradients, but they are decent enough. I'd personally like to see just one straight gradient or pure color through the whole signature; but that's just me .

2) I think this is just over the top in terms of forms, color, and effects. Too much going on here. I'd like to maybe see one color, one form and just maybe one shine effect.

3) This one is like number two except it uses only one color, so it's better in that sense, unfortunately your face just seems to be pasted on there so you lose out in that aspect. I think this one might work if the face is integrated a little better. The slogan also doesn't make much sense to me: "Never Let a Chance" ? Not really sure what you are saying, and why is everything capitlized but the a?

Alright, I think I did enough damage for one day, but seriously, I hope my comments help you.
_________________
The Gamer's Journal | Online Portfolio | Half-Life Library

[marinaroz]

Okay, here's my review:

The first signature looks nice, but it's somewhat plain, lacking a certain flair. maybe because there's too much grey and too much empty space it it. I do like the photograph on it though, it's the best photograph of the three.

The second signature is my overall favorite of the bunch. It has a nice color theme which I like. The blending between the graphics and the photo can use some work, though. It doesn't have the appearance of a particularly smooth transition. Also, you overuse the 3D effects. Tone them down a bit, or try some other effect maybe. The pattern on your sig is very pretty I love it.

The third signature is extremely overcrowded and uses a bad looking font. The message of that signature is very unclear too. I say scrape it.
_________________
Tarakana NET

[dylan2xs]

the first one is really good